To Fill a Pond With Fish

It’s Baobhan Sith, funnily enough, who kickstarts this realization.

“Mother!” She storms into her room, “is it true that you’re looking to adopt another?”

 Morgan barely pauses her reading. “It is not.”

“Oh.” Baobhan Sith stops in her tracks. “You do not have any other apprentice?”

“I do not.” Morgan had thought her first response had been clear on the subject. She slides a bookmark between the pages, then sets the book down. “I do not want any, and no one has asked for me to be their mentor.” Perhaps this elaboration will clear Baobhan Sith’s mind.

Unfortunately, it does not. Baobhan Sith frowns, scowls. Opens her mouth. Closes it.

“Speak your mind.”

A short pause. And then: “Then why do you keep seeing Mash?”

What an odd question. “I have no intent to take this knight as a daughter.” Besides, Sir Kyrielight is already quite the capable knight on her own. And her affinity with magecraft is quite poor anyways. “Sir Kyrielight is merely…”

… What is Sir Kyrielight to her?

Not an apprentice, this has been established. In fact, Morgan would ever go as far as to say that she considers Sir Kyrielight her equal in strength and status- not someone she should ever have to educate or protect. So that makes them… comrades, perhaps? Companions in arms? The words don’t seem to quite fit, though. Describing Sir Kyrielight as merely anything sounds like an insult, really. Morgan has nothing but the utmost respect for this knight beholden to no one but her ideals-

“Mother…?”

 “I will tell you in due time.” She shouldn’t give an answer unless she is certain of it. Certainly, Morgan can figure it out in a couple hours at most.


She does not figure it out in a couple hours. Nor in five hours. Nor in twelve hours.

The Master of Chaldea raises an eyebrow. “I don’t… really know what you expect of me here.”

“Spouse of mine, if there is one person in this facility who can take pride in having every relationship known to man, it’s you. Surely you of all people can help me fix this issue in my vocabulary.”

They stare at her for a few second, then sigh, reaching out to grab a pen and a paper. “Alright. First thing first. Would you consider your relationship with Mash to be positive or negative?”

“Positive. I have nothing but the utmost respect for Sir Kyrielight. She is what every knight should aspire to be like.”

They jot down a couple things. “Do you want her to pledge allegiance to you?”

“Negative. I do not wish for any sort of hierarchy to exist between us.”

“So. She’s a friend.”

Morgan pauses for a moment. A friend… she sincerely hadn’t considered the possibility. “I suppose so.”

“You don’t seem satisfied with that label.”

“I’m not sure I am.” She thinks it over for a second. “Habetrot is a… friend. She is my equal, and someone dear to me. But Sir Kyrielight is… different.” Not necessarily more or less, just… different.

“Do you perhaps want her as your wife?”

That would be politically advantageous. Mash is the oldest servant in Chaldea. She is a respected and beloved member of this community, as she should be. There is no reason why Morgan shouldn’t want Mash as a wife. “I… do not believe so. Framing our relationship through political lenses makes me… uncomfortable.”

The Master taps their pen against the desk. “Okay, let’s tackle this from another angle. What do you want from Mash.”

“Want? I do not wish to take advantage of her in any ways.”

“I know, I know, I didn’t mean it like that. I meant… you seek her out for tea parties, right? Among other things?”

She does, indeed. “I see. I do want her company.”

“Why is that?”

“I find it enjoyable. She makes me feel…” Well. She makes Morgan feel, period. Which is already a feat in itself.

The Master makes a vague gesture of the hand. “If you don’t know what you’re feeling, then describe the physical sensations to me. Bring your metaphor game, I don’t mind.”

Her spouse truly is wiser than they seem. “Warm. And soft. It is rather pleasant.” If Morgan’s soul is water, then being near Mash is the difference between a stagnant puddle and a lake full of life.

“Happy, then.” Ah. Is that what it is? Morgan prides herself in her knowledge, but she will admit she has grown… disconnected, to her own heart. “You know what I think, Morgan?”

“I think you have figured it all out. So you could directly tell me the answer.”

“I think you should go see Mash. Spend some time with her. Examine what that makes you feel and hand. And if you still can’t figure it out by then, come to see me again, alright?”


Well, that was wildly unhelpful.

At least being with Mash calms her frustration somewhat. They’re watching a movie, though Morgan can’t be bothered to pay attention to it. Her mind is still busy on the puzzle that is her relationship with the knight, rotating it in her head.

How does Mash make her feel? She’s laying her head on Morgan’s shoulder right now. Mash is not afraid of her; never has. She’s amongst the bravest people Morgan has ever known. This makes her feel… trusted. Comfortable. The only other times Morgan recalls feeling something similar was with Uther, and (and?)

“I think the butler did it.” Mash speculates out loud. She likes to do that a lot. Her love for mystery stories is quite endearing. “He had this one line at the beginning of the movie, it has to be foreshadowing.”

Her hand is on her own thigh, inches away from Morgan’s own. On impulse, Morgan grabs it. Mash startles at the sudden touch, turning to look at her- but, after a few seconds without any explanation on Morgan’s part, she turns back to look at the screen.

It’s a nice hand. Small. Calloused, as she (knew it would be) expected from a knight. Morgan slides her fingers between Mash’s. Her own hand is rather big in comparison. Her skin is pretty soft. Morgan has half a mind to bring it up to her face- the lips, after all, are among the most sensitive parts of a body. Surely kissing it would feel… would…

Ah.

“I see. I understand now.” Suddenly, her spouse’s reluctance to tell her their thoughts makes a lot more sense. She really had to pierce it together herself.

“You figured out the culprit, Morgan?” Mash tilts her head to look up at her, eyes half-hidden beneath her hair. Morgan thinks she could look at these eyes for years and never grow bored.

She reaches out for the tv remote, and pauses the movie. “Apologies. I have realized something of the utmost importance, and this cannot wait.”

“Oh.” Mash shuffles back to sit properly. She almost takes her hand back, but Morgan applies the tiniest of pressure, just to show reluctance, and Mash does not insist. “What’s wrong?”

Hm. Perhaps Morgan should have studied the matter more before speaking up. This is, after all, not something she has ever done herself. However, now that she is aware of her own feelings, she finds herself reluctant to keep them inside. These have been caged up for (months) (decades) (centuries) so long, little fish begging to be let back into the pond. If Mash accepts them, let them roam free; if Mash refuses them, let Morgan cull them herself.

“I would like to court you.”

Mash’s eyes widen. A slight blush rises up her cheeks. “I-I’m sorry?”

“We are friends. I would like to be lovers.” Lovers. That’s the word she was looking for. Lovers. This is what she would like to tell Baobhan Sith. She and I are lovers. “However, I understand that this is an important change to request so suddenly. So if you will allow me, I would like to court you.”

Mash stares at her. That is understandable. That realization was a surprise to Morgan too. Mash stares at her, and she-

Starts crying.

Her chest hiccups. Her breathing stutters. Tears roll onto her cheeks.

… Ah.

“Apologies. It seems that I made you upset.” This is alright. Morgan should have expected that outcome. This is fine. It was foolish of her to think otherwise, really. This is no fault of Mash. “I will take my lea-”

“Don’t you dare!” Mash’s hand suddenly tightens around her own. “Don’t- don’t leave me. I- these are h-happy tears, I swear.”

Oh. That’s. Oh. Is that relief she feels? This emotion like a wave cleansing her from the inside out?

“I just,” Mash continues, sniffling, “I thought I’d never- you- I thought- I thought I had lost- for good-”

She starts about a dozen sentences, and finish none of them. Whatever Morgan has done, it evoked something powerful enough in Mash to shake her to her core.

She still hasn’t let go of Morgan’s hand, though.

“May I hold you until you calm down?”

Mash nods frantically. Through the tears, she smiles, and it’s like the spring after a harsh winter. “I- I would like that very much, yes.”

Halcyon722: Big fan of Baobhan Sith popping up. My mind lights up thinking about the potential for hilarity in Morgan one day telling her "Mash is your step-mom now". I especially enjoy the ever-present undercurrent, nay, the foundation of Morgan and Mash's relationship of how Morgan just feels all these (to her) inexplicable feelings about Mash and is unable to properly articulate them. Of course Morgan doesn't know, but Tonelico did. Just because she can't remember doesn't mean it wasn't real, and little by little, it starts coming back to her.

BIG fan of Ritsuka being something of an interpreter for Morgan's emotions. Like, I'd probably blow through the character limit if I went into it, but I am floored when I think about Ritsuka, this average Joe, this complete schmuck who could have been literally anybody, being the emotional anchor to, not just Morgan, but all the servants under their care. It's about HUMANITY and CONNECTION and I am GNASHING MY TEETH thinking about some fucking NOBODY being haunted by all these (pretty much literal) ghosts across all of time and human culture and for the servants to lean on Ritsuka as much as Ritsuka leans on them. Turns out, if you get haunted by a bunch of ghosts, you'll eventually haunt them back. This small, intimate scene of Morgan asking Ritsuka for help processing her emotions is a beautiful distillation of what (to me at least) Fate is all ABOUT.

I adore the low-key comedy of Morgan, the unbelievably powerful and imposing Witch Queen of Camelot, just sitting and watching a fucking movie with her gf. The contrast in situation vs. the characters IN the situation is delightful. I am then immediately gutted by "The only other times Morgan recalls feeling something similar was with Uther, and (and?)". How cruel you are, Verse, to put such a fucking banger to words. IT ALL COMES BACK to that idea of Morgan not being directly aware, but still remembering what Tonelico felt towards Mash. I'm just repeating myself, but god fucking DAMN if Tonelico/Morgan's whole... everything ain't one of the most poignant fucking things I've experienced in all of fiction, and I'm more than content to immerse myself in it repeatedly.

Anyway, so then finally Morgan makes her feelings clear, and it's like a wave of catharsis washing over me. For Morgan, someone who basically never expresses herself, to finally just SAY IT, to speak it into existence and make her love real, it makes my heart sing. Side note, but usually stoic characters finally showing how much they care about their loved ones is GOOD SHIT.

"She starts about a dozen sentences, and finish none of them." is also just a really good line. Not much more to add, I just really like it! As I've come to expect, lots of emphasis on hands here (and I love it!), and that closing line "...and it’s like the spring after a harsh winter." fucking ROCKS. Because Morgan's the WINTER QUEEN. AAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH I can't even articulate how good that is, words truly fail me in this moment to really convey how much I love that line.

All in all, you've woven yet another ruinously beautiful piece about these two. I'm fucking giddy to think that my emotional vomit has in any way spurred the creation of more art. I'm left hooting and hollering anytime I see a new upload, and my only concern is that you'll write too quickly for me to keep up!

Subjective_Thought: I'm in bed sick at the moment and I can't tell these are making me better or giving me brainworms instead. I am rapidly becoming rabid, this is such a good freaking ship. Thank you very much for these stories.

anta_permana: LAWD THE MASHMORGAN FEELS HELL YEAH

TheRank5Ninja: A+++ ranking. Simply flawless!

Krisg142: This is that good shit. I love it